Zwabel’s Weblog

March 30, 2009

Pushing Immature Technology onto the User

Filed under: KDE — zwabel @ 10:52 pm
Tags: , , , ,

KDE4’s new Desktop shell called Plasma is meant to do everything better then KDE3’s kickoff+kdesktop did. Innovations over innovations, exciting stuff is going on there. The development goes on in a high pace, and with every release there is new features all over the place. It would be a really great project, if there wasn’t one tiny little problem: It is the core desktop shell of one of the 2 major linux distributions, still they refuse to care about a large part of their current/potential users. Yes, I’m talking about the poor souls who don’t have good enough hardware for full desktop composition, don’t have good enough graphics drivers for stable desktop composition, or the rebels like me, who simply cannot stand the slight lag always feelable on a composited desktop.

I don’t even want to open a discussion on graphics drivers here. Fact is, I have very good graphics hardware, but when using composition, you _always_ pay a price for it, especially when you have a 3280×1200 Desktop setup, and when your system is under heavy load. As desktop composition becomes more popular, the drivers are maturing, but still the general architecture is far from perfect.

Apart from that, a 2000 MHZ computer with 512 MB of ram and without a 3D accelerator card should be able to run any good desktop environment without problems, and it should even be able to look good. There is no technical reason speaking against it. I don’t consider Windows Vista a good desktop environment in this regard btw.

I also don’t want to start a discussion on desktop composition in general. I want to start a discussion on the way those people are treated, who do not want to jump on using the newest immature technology, or simply aren’t able to.

Now along came Plasma. It has tons of beautiful themes available that are downloadable through GetHotNewStuff. The only problem: Most of those themes look like total crap when composition is disabled, because plasma does not allow the panel to blend over the underlying desktop without desktop composition. 100% exact transparency by definition can not be achieved without composition, but all desktop environments except KDE4 support something called “fake transparency”, where the panel uses a blended version of the underlying wallpaper as background, which leads to a nearly correct result, with the only downside that windows covered by the panel are not visible through it. But seriously, who puts windows under his panel, and wants to see them?

However, and I knew this before, the plasma developer consider something like that an evil ugly hack, and don’t want to put something like it into plasma.

Since I’m an aesthetically sensitive person, I got tired of the grey brick at the bottom of my right screen, and put a few evenings into finding out how hacky it would really be to make it look nice. It couldn’t be that hard, after all the plasmoids on the desktops themselves also use the same software aka. fake transparency. And behold: Due to the fact that the desktop and panel live in the same application, and because of the logical API, in the end it turned out quite easy to do, and quite un-hacky. It works unbelievably well: Wallpaper blending animations, moving plasmoids under the panel, or putting animated plasmoids under it works exactly as expected. Here you can see the result. About 80 added lines of code, no evil stuff, no API added, and this result:

Before (Actually this is one of very few themes that don’t look like total crap without composition):

After (To my eyes, about 100 times more beautiful than before):

Still, not the slightest interest in adding this. To them it might be a hack, but to me, it is the only way of achieving a nicely looking desktop without composition. 80 Lines of code, for at least 36% of all linux users(According to this survey, in my experience it would be even more).

Instead, I get told that I should use composition(btw. games run a lot slower with nvidia just from enabling it in the xorg.conf), I get told that drivers are getting better, and I get told that hardware is getting more powerful. And this is where I see a basic problem with plasma: They seem to be developing for the future, and only give a small part of their attention to the present.
I don’t care whether future drivers will be better, I don’t care whether future system tray specifications will be better, when at the same time my desktop does not look nice, my systemtray doesn’t work properly, and my krunner doesn’t run the commands I type. KDE4 is a technology of _today_, and should work _today_, for everyone.

This goes for all of KDE4: I sincerely hope that in future, we can find a better balance between innovative development, and present usability.

Create a free website or blog at